Prepared by the Imperial Cushions editorial team. Laboratory terminology is retained where a report is cited; historical context and dealer judgment are identified as interpretation.
Old mine cuts and modern cushion brilliants share a softly squared family of outlines. Their facet arrangements give you a much wider choice of appearance than the shape name suggests.
Follow the central pattern
Old mine cuts commonly have a visible culet, small table and broad facets. Modern cushion brilliants use several pavilion arrangements; GIA describes four- and eight-main versions and modified patterns with additional facets. Compare the size of the reflections and how much activity appears near the centre and edges.
Start with the 3.01 ct old mine cushion, then view the 7.51 ct cushion brilliant. Their photographs show different facet spacing and outlines. The size difference makes equally scaled images especially useful.
Choose through comparison
Watch each stone under the same light, at the same distance and through a slow rotation. Decide whether you prefer large, distinct flashes or a more closely packed pattern. Check condition and setting requirements before committing.
GIA’s cushion-cut guide explains the main facet arrangements. Our light-return article shows how to read them in motion.
Two cushions, two philosophies
Both styles share a cushion outline. The difference is in what the cutter was trying to achieve. The Old Mine cut was shaped by hand to save weight and to sparkle in candlelight. The modern cushion brilliant is planned with computer models to maximise brightness under modern lighting, usually from carefully selected rough.
Facet structure
An Old Mine cut has fewer, larger facets, a small table, a high crown and an open culet. A modern cushion brilliant has a larger table, a lower crown, a pointed culet and, often, additional pavilion facets. Laboratories may describe modern variants as “cushion brilliant” or “cushion modified brilliant”; the modified versions tend to show a finer, more fragmented sparkle sometimes called a “crushed ice” look.
How each one looks
- Old Mine cut: broad flashes of white and coloured light, strong contrast, a visible culet, and a sense of depth when you look into the stone.
- Cushion brilliant: high overall brightness, many small points of light, and a more uniform face-up pattern.
Neither is better in principle. The choice depends on whether you prefer bold, slow flashes and visible character, or maximum brightness and a cleaner, contemporary look.
Size and spread
Because Old Mine cuts often carry weight in a high crown and deep pavilion, they can face up smaller than a modern cushion of the same carat weight. Always compare measurements in millimetres. A well-proportioned Old Mine cut can still spread well; the point is to check rather than assume.
Colour and clarity
Old Mine cuts often show body colour slightly more than modern brilliants, because their broad facets do not mask it with sparkle. Many buyers enjoy a touch of warmth in an antique stone. Inclusions can also be easier to see through the small table and open culet, so clarity should be judged on the stone itself and not only on the grade.
Price and availability
Modern cushions are cut to order from available rough. Original Old Mine cuts cannot be made again: the supply is limited to stones that have survived, and good examples in larger sizes are genuinely scarce. That scarcity, rather than the cut alone, is what drives the premium on fine antique stones.
Seeing them side by side
The clearest way to decide is to watch both styles move on video under the same light. We can prepare a side-by-side presentation from our stones so you can compare them directly before choosing.


