Reviewed 16 November 2026

Prepared by the Imperial Cushions editorial team. Laboratory terminology is retained where a report is cited; historical context and dealer judgment are identified as interpretation.

A dealer’s assessment should explain why a particular diamond holds the eye. Useful observations describe the outline, transparency, facet pattern, condition and how the stone could work in a finished jewel.

Make the comparison specific

The 8.01 ct H VVS2 cushion has a nearly square 11.72 × 11.60 mm face. The 9.04 ct F IF cushion is more elongated at 14.45 × 12.02 mm. Their outlines suggest different proportions for a ring, even before comparing colour or clarity.

Ask the dealer to point to the features behind an opinion. Which corners give the outline its shape? Where do the largest flashes appear? How visible are the clarity features in ordinary light? A demonstration makes the assessment useful.

Discuss the trade-offs

One stone may offer the shape you love with a more visible inclusion. Another may have a cleaner appearance and a deeper profile. Bring those details together with the setting, condition and price before deciding what matters most to you.

Use the evaluation guide to keep your own comparison notes, or request a private presentation of the stones that interest you.

What dealers mean by character

Character is the sum of the things a grading report does not fully capture: how a diamond moves, the pattern and size of its flashes, the shape of its outline, the visible culet, the way it holds colour, and the sense that it was cut by a person rather than a machine. Two stones with identical reports can feel completely different in the hand.

The questions a dealer asks

  • Outline. Is the shape balanced and pleasing, even if it is not perfectly symmetrical? Are the corners well rounded and even?
  • Crown. Is it high enough to produce bold flashes? Does it carry weight that does not show face up?
  • Culet. Is the open culet a pleasing size, centred, and in proportion to the table?
  • Face-up size. Does the stone look its weight, or does it hide weight in depth?
  • Life. In movement, does light travel across the whole stone, or are there dead areas?
  • Colour. Is the body colour attractive, and is it even across the stone?
  • Originality and condition. Is the cut original? Are there chips, repairs or signs of recutting?

Why symmetry is judged differently

A modern diamond is expected to be close to perfectly symmetrical. Antique diamonds rarely are, because cutters worked by eye and saved weight wherever they could. Dealers accept slight asymmetry if the stone is beautiful, and they become cautious only when it creates a visible imbalance or a weak point.

Reading character from a distance

If you cannot see the stone in person, ask for the same views a dealer would want: a face-up video in daylight and in indoor light, a side profile showing crown and pavilion, a view on the hand, and the full report. Ask the dealer to describe the stone in their own words. A specific description is a good sign that the stone has actually been examined.

Character and value

In antique diamonds, character can move value as much as the colour or clarity grade. A beautifully shaped Old Mine cushion with an attractive culet and strong life can be worth more than a higher-graded stone without them. This is why we write our own description for every stone we offer, alongside the laboratory report.

Learning to see it yourself

The fastest way to develop an eye is to compare. Ask to see two or three stones side by side on video under the same light, and note which one you keep returning to. That instinct is usually what dealers mean by character.