Reviewed 16 November 2026

Prepared by the Imperial Cushions editorial team. Laboratory terminology is retained where a report is cited; historical context and dealer judgment are identified as interpretation.

A pair of antique diamonds should look balanced together in size, outline, colour and movement. Begin with the face-up dimensions, then view both stones beside each other under the same light.

View them as earrings

Place the stones in matching holders, at the same angle and distance. Look first at the outlines, then at the colour and the size of the broad reflections. Rotate both together and check whether one consistently appears darker or more active. Repeat near the face, where earrings will be seen.

Read both reports and examine the clarity features individually. The setter also needs the two side profiles, girdle maps and culet clearances to plan matching finished heights.

Ask for a paired video and a setting discussion through Inspection and Service. The setting guide covers the support and clearance questions.

What makes a pair match

A true pair is chosen by eye first and by paper second. Two diamonds can share a carat weight and still look different on the ear. What matters is how they face up side by side: outline, apparent size, colour, brightness and the pattern of light across the facets.

  • Outline and proportions. Cushions should share a similar length-to-width ratio and corner shape. A slightly squarer stone next to a slightly longer one is noticeable at conversation distance.
  • Face-up size in millimetres. Compare measurements, not only carat weight. Old cuts with high crowns or deep pavilions can carry weight that does not show face up.
  • Colour. Aim for the same grade or adjacent grades with the same tone. A warm stone beside a cool one is harder to hide than a one-grade difference.
  • Culet and crown. In Old Mine cushions the open culet is visible through the table. Similar culet size and crown height help the pair read as one.
  • Brightness and pattern. Watch both stones move together on video. They should flash in a similar rhythm.

Why antique pairs take time

Antique diamonds were cut individually, by hand, to save weight from each rough crystal. No two are identical, and matched pairs that have stayed together since they were cut are rare. Most antique pairs today are assembled by dealers over months or years. When a good match appears, it is often worth securing quickly; when a match is forced, it usually shows.

Choosing the earring style

Studs show the face-up view directly, so outline and colour matching matter most. Drops move and catch light from many angles, which can forgive a small difference in proportion but makes any difference in brightness more visible. For larger stones, weight and the security of the fitting matter as much as appearance: discuss post and clip type with your jeweller before the setting is designed.

Documents for a pair

Ask for an individual report for each stone. Check that colour, clarity, measurements and fluorescence are compatible, and that both reports are recent enough to reflect the stones as they are today. Keep the reports together with the jewel for insurance and for any future sale.

How we can help

If you already own one stone, we can look for a partner to it. Send the report and a face-up photograph or video, together with the earring style you have in mind, and we will tell you honestly how close a match is likely to be.